DA charges San Diego, Los Angeles ‘Antifa’ groups with violently countering Pacific Beach ‘Patriot March’
At least 11 anti-fascists face counts based on conspiracy to commit a riot; they’re also charged with assaults and using tear gas
Prosecutors on Monday charged at least seven people, whom they described as self-identified anti-fascists, in connection with eight alleged assaults that occurred in January during a Pacific Beach “Patriot March” organized by supporters of then-President Donald Trump.
Those arraigned Monday in San Diego Superior Court were among a group arrested Thursday in raids by police officers and sheriff’s deputies across Southern California. Prosecutors allege the defendants “are self-identified to be affiliated with Anti-fascists or Antifa,” according to a criminal complaint, and began organizing themselves — with one group originating in San Diego and the other in Los Angeles — a week before the pro-Trump rally.
Police officials said they made 8 arrests Thursday and an additional arrest warrant was issued; they face conspiracy and other charges
The case is believed to be one of the first to use conspiracy charges — in this case conspiracy to commit riot — to target alleged members of “Antifa,” a term often used to describe the anti-fascist movement.
The Center for Strategic and International Studies describes “Antifa” as a “decentralized network of far-left militants who oppose what they believe are fascist, racist, or otherwise right-wing extremists” and whose adherents “frequently blend anarchist and communist views.” Anti-fascists typically don’t shy away from clashes, instead using what they call “direct action” to confront the systems, groups and individuals they view as their political enemies.
According to a criminal complaint, the defendants charged Monday began their criminal conspiracy “by liking and sharing” a Jan. 2 social media post that called for a counterprotest against the pro-Trump rally, “in essence agreeing to take part in the ‘direct action.’ Others agreed by showing up in Pacific Beach on January 9th, 2021 and participating in the violence” detailed in the complaint, prosecutors alleged.
They’re accused of using pepper spray, small flag poles, sticks and other items to attack the pro-Trump crowd Jan. 9 on the streets and boardwalk near Crystal Pier. Demonstrators at that rally held signs and flags adorned with “Stop the Steal,” “Trump 2020" and other similar messages just days after the Jan. 6 insurrection at the Capitol in Washington, D.C.
San Diego police declared an unlawful gathering but later allowed Trump supporters to march
Several of the attacks detailed in the complaint appear to match incidents that were recorded and shared online, such as a video of an anti-fascist counterprotester pepper spraying a dog and its owner. Prosecutors allege that act was committed by Jeremy Jonathan White, 39, one of the defendants who remained jailed Monday in lieu of $200,000 bail. White faces charges of conspiracy, assault with a deadly weapon, use of tear gas not in self-defense and animal cruelty.
A Los Angeles-based videographer captured a nearly two-minute-long attack by counterprotesters involving the use of pepper spray, a wooden folding chair thrown through the air, sticks, punches and kicks. Prosecutors detailed an identical attack in the complaint.
Those arraigned Monday, according to the District Attorney’s Office, were White; Luis Francisco Mora, 30; Joseph Austin Gaskins, 21; Faraz Martin Talab, 27; Bryan Rivera, 21; Brian Lightfoot, 25; and Jesse Merel Cannon, 31.
Also facing charges, according to a spokesperson for the District Attorney’s Office, are Alexander Akridge-Jacobs, 31; Christian Martinez, 23; and Samuel Howard Ogden, 24.
A $250,000 arrest warrant has been issued for Erich Louis Yach, 37, according to the District Attorney’s Office and county Sheriff’s Department records.
Information about defense attorneys for the defendants was not available Monday evening. An attorney who represents one of the defendants in two other criminal cases did not immediately return phone and email messages seeking comment.
Some observers questions whether police showed bias in the way they responded to Trump supporters versus counterprotesters, some of whom identified as anti-fascist
Though reporters and bystanders also documented violence committed by the pro-Trump rallygoers — one video showed a group attacking a barefoot man in a George Floyd T-shirt, including one man who spit on him and sucker punched him — the District Attorney’s Office alleged most of the violence was carried out by the left-wing counterprotesters.
“Video evidence analysis shows that overwhelmingly the violence in this incident was perpetrated by the Antifa affiliates and was not a mutual fray with both sides crossing out of lawful First Amendment expression into riot and violence,” District Attorney Summer Stephan’s office said in a news release.
Stephan’s office said in the release that prosecutors file charges when evidence supports the allegations beyond a reasonable doubt, regardless of the political affiliation of victims, because “the right to peaceful protest must be protected.”
Stephan spokesman Steve Walker noted that in August of last year, two men who were charged in connection with an attack on Black Lives Matter protesters in Imperial Beach. During the June 2020 demonstration, a Black man who was recording the event was sucker punched and protesters were insulted and had eggs thrown at them.
One of the defendants pleaded guilty to felony assault and the second pleaded guilty to felony battery. Both men also pleaded guilty to hate-crime allegations. They were sentenced to probation in April.
Staff writer David Hernandez contributed to this report.